City@path: A Collaborative Smart City Planning and Assessment Tool

City@path: A Collaborative Smart City Planning and Assessment Tool

Diogo Correia JoÃo Lourenço Marques Leonor Teixeira

University of Aveiro, Portugal

Available online: 
| Citation

© 2022 IIETA. This article is published by IIETA and is licensed under the CC BY 4.0 license (



‘The lack of strategic planning has increased urban pressure and accumulated traffic in cities. Smart Cities are replacing the short-time perspective with a long-term approach. The objectives align with city strategic goals, and citizens play an essential role in the decision-making process. High-level guidelines have emerged over the years to guide Smart Cities’ vision and implementation. However, the lack of a tool that combines top-down and bottom-up approaches to help local policymakers plan and assess cities is still notorious. Moreover, this paper provides a methodology that allows the definition of structural priorities and contextual preferences while comparing policymakers’ statements and citizens’ opinions. Furthermore, this paper designs an approach to fill the existing gap and give policymakers a framework to monitor and measure their performance based on standard Key Performance Indicators and select relevant initiatives toward meeting the defined goals. This way, policymakers possess a tool that allows on the one hand, the standard comparison between cities and, on the other hand, the personalized comparison of their territory over time. Finally, a test case with the premise of improving city logistics is described to practically detail the guidelines of the proposed tool’.


assessment, logistics, participatory development, smart city, transportation


[1] H. Chourabi et al., Understanding smart cities: An integrative framework. Proc. Annu. Hawaii Int. Conf. Syst. Sci., no. July 2014, pp. 2289–2297, 2012.

[2] United Nations, World Urbanization Prospects. 2015.

[3] 2012 OECD, OECD (2012), OECD Environmental Outlook to 2050, OECD Publishing. 2012.

[4] P., Neirotti, A., De Marco, A. C., Cagliano, G., Mangano and F., Scorrano, Current trends in Smart City initiatives : Some stylised facts. Cities, 38, pp. 25–36, 2014.

[5] S. E., Bibri and J., Krogstie, Smart sustainable cities of the future: An extensive interdisciplinary literature review. Sustain. Cities Soc., 31, pp. 183–212, 2017.

[6] L. G., Anthopoulos and A. Vakali, Urban Planning and Smart Cities : Interrelations and Reciprocities Urban Planning : Principles and Dimensions. Lect. Notes Comput. Sci., 7281, pp. 178–189, 2012.

[7] A., Meijer and M. P. R., Bolívar, Governing the smart city: a review of the literature on smart urban governance. Int. Rev. Adm. Sci., 82(2), pp. 392–408, 2016.

[8] T., Nam and T. A., Pardo, Smart city as urban innovation. Proc. 5th Int. Conf. Theory Pract. Electron. Gov. - ICEGOV ’11, p. 185, 2011.

[9] Harrison Colin and I. A., Donnelly, A Theory of Smart Cities, 91, pp. 399–404, 2017.

[10] P., Newman, T., Beatley and H., Boyer, Resilient cities: Overcoming fossil fuel dependence. Island Press, 2017.

[11] P., Gurstein and T., Hutton, Planning on the Edge: Vancouver and the Challenges of Reconciliation, Social Justice, and Sustainable Development. UBC Press, 2019.

[12] L., Adkins, M., Cooper and M., Konings, Class in the 21st century: Asset inflation and the new logic of inequality. Environ. Plan. A, 0,(0), pp. 1–25, 2019.

[13] C., Moreno, Z., Allam, D., Chabaud, C., Gall and F., Pratlong, Introducing the ‘15-Minute City’: Sustainability, Resilience and Place Identity in Future Post-Pandemic Cities. Smart Cities, 4(1), pp. 93–111, 2021.

[14] F., Arnold, I., Cardenas, K., Sörensen and W., Dewulf, Simulation of B2C e-commerce distribution in Antwerp using cargo bikes and delivery points. Eur. Transp. Res. Rev., 10(1), 2018.

[15] L., Carter and F., Bélanger, The utilization of e-government services: Citizen trust, innovation and acceptance factors. Inf. Syst. J., 15(1), pp. 5–25, 2005.

[16] D., Correia, J., Feio, L., Teixeira and J. L., Marques, The Inclusion of Citizens in Smart Cities Policymaking: The Potential Role of Development Studies’ Participatory Methodologies, in Distributed, Ambient and Pervasive Interactions, N. Streitz and S. Konomi, Eds. Springer Nature Switzerland AG, 2021.

[17] H. M., Mathur, Participatory development: Some areas of current concern. Sociol. Bull., 46(1), pp. 53–95, 1997.

[18] C., Gore, The Rise and Fall of the Washington Consensus as a Paradigm for Developing Countries. 28(5), 2000.

[19] D., Mosse, Authority, Gender and Knowledge: Theoretical Reflections on the Practice of Participatory Rural Appraisal. Dev. Change, 25(3), pp. 497–526, 1994.

[20] G., Mohan and K., Stokke, Participatory development and empowerment: the dangers of localism. Third World Q., 21(2), pp. 247–268, 2000.

[21] B., Cooke and U., Kothari, Participation: The new tyranny?, Zed books, 2001.

[22] S., Hickey and G., Mohan, Participation: from tyranny to transformation: exploring new approaches to participation in development, Zed books, 2004.

[23] Á., Oliveira and Margarida Campolargo, From Smart Cities to Human Smart Cities, in 48th Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences, 2015.

[24] T., Shelton, M., Zook, and A., Wiig, The ‘actually existing smart city’. Cambridge J. Reg. Econ. Soc., 8(1), pp. 13–25, 2015.

[25] L., Dablanc, Logistics Sprawl and Urban Freight Planning Issues in a Major Gateway City : The Case of Los Angeles. Sustain. Urban Logist. Concepts, Methods Inf. Syst., pp. 49–69, 2014.

[26] R., Nocerino, A., Colorni, F., Lia and A., Luè, E-bikes and E-scooters for Smart Logistics: Environmental and Economic Sustainability in Pro-E-bike Italian Pilots. Transp. Res. Procedia, 14, pp. 2362–2371, 2016.

[27] F., Russo, C., Rindone and P., Panuccio, European plans for the smart city: from theories and rules to logistics test case. Eur. Plan. Stud., 24(9), pp. 1709–1726, 2016.

[28] J. H. R., Van Duin, W., De Goffau, B., Wiegmans, L. A., Tavasszy and M., Saes, Improving Home Delivery Efficiency by Using Principles of Address Intelligence for B2C Deliveries. Transp. Res. Procedia, 12, no. June 2015, pp. 14–25, 2016.

[29] J., Visser, T., Nemoto and M., Browne, Home Delivery and the Impacts on Urban Freight Transport: A Review. Procedia - Soc. Behav. Sci., 125, pp. 15–27, 2014.

[30] T., Eiichi and K., Yasushi, Modelling Effects of E-commerce on Urban Freight Transport, in Logistics Systems for Sustainable Cities, E. Taniguchi and R. G. Thompson, Eds. Emerald Group Publishing Limited, pp. 135–146, 2004.

[31] V., Gatta, E., Marcucci, M., Nigro, S. M., Patella and S., Serafini, Public transport-based crowdshipping for sustainable city logistics: Assessing economic and environmental impacts. Sustain., 11(1), pp. 1–14, 2018.

[32] E., Morganti, L., Dablanc and F., Fortin, Final deliveries for online shopping: The deployment of pickup point networks in urban and suburban areas. Res. Transp. Bus. Manag., 11, pp. 23–31, 2014.

[33] R., Ducret, Parcel deliveries and urban logistics: Changes and challenges in the courier express and parcel sector in Europe - The French case. Res. Transp. Bus. Manag., 11, pp. 15–22, 2014.

[34] eMarketer, Global Ecommerce 2019, [Online]. Available: content/global-ecommerce-2019, 2019 [Accessed: 15-Aug-2020].

[35] E., Taniguchi, R. G., Thompson and T., Yamada, New Opportunities and Challenges for City Logistics. Transp. Res. Procedia, 12, June 2015, pp. 5–13, 2016.

[36] L., Zhou, R., Baldacci, D., Vigo and X., Wang, A Multi-Depot Two-Echelon Vehicle Routing Problem with Delivery Options Arising in the Last Mile Distribution. Eur. J. Oper. Res., 265(2), pp. 765–778, 2018.

[37] L., Zhou, X., Wang, L., Ni and Y., Lin, Location-routing problem with simultaneous home delivery and customer’s pickup for city distribution of online shopping purchases. Sustain., 8(8), 2016.

[38] S., Lee, Y., Kang and V. V., Prabhu, Smart logistics: distributed control of green crowdsourced parcel services. Int. J. Prod. Res., 54(23), pp. 6956–6968, 2016.

[39] UN, Sustainable development goals, [Online]. Available: sustainabledevelopment/sustainable-development-goals, 2018.

[40] EC, A European Green Deal, [Online]. Available: priorities-2019-2024/european-green-deal_en#policy-areas, 2019. [Accessed: 21-Oct2020].

[41] European Commission, The European Green Deal, 2019.

[42] M., Angelidou, Smart city policies: A spatial approach. Cities, 41, pp. S3–S11, 2014.

[43] S., Zygiaris, Smart City Reference Model: Assisting Planners to Conceptualize the Building of Smart City Innovation Ecosystems. J. Knowl. Econ., 4(2), pp. 217–231, 2013.

[44] S. P., Mohanty, U., Choppali and E., Kougianos, Everything you wanted to know about smart cities. IEEE Consum. Electron. Mag., 5(3), pp. 60–70, 2016.

[45] L., Mora, R., Bolici and M., Deakin, The First Two Decades of Smart-City Research: A Bibliometric Analysis. J. Urban Technol., 24(1), pp. 3–27, 2017.

[46] M., Tan, Creating the Digital Economy: Strategies and Perspectives from Singapore. Int. J. Electron. Commer., 3(3), pp. 105–122, 1999.

[47] M., Angelidou, Smart cities: A conjuncture of four forces. Cities, 47, pp. 95–106, 2015.

[48] A., Mainka, W., Castelnovo, V., Miettinen, S., Bech-Petersen, S., Hartmann and W. G., Stock, Open innovation in smart cities: Civic participation and co-creation of public services. Proc. Assoc. Inf. Sci. Technol., 53(1), pp. 1–5, 2016.

[49] S., Al-Nasrawi, A., El-Zaart and C., Adams, The Anatomy of Smartness of Smart Sustainable Cities: An Inclusive Approach. 2017 Int. Conf. Comput. Appl. ICCA 2017, pp. 348–353, 2017.

[50] R., Pérez-Delhoyo, H., Mora, R., Abad-Ortiz and R., Mollá-Sirvent, Social networks of sport and their potential in smart urban planning processes. Int. J. Transp. Dev. Integr., 4(1), pp. 62–74, 2020.

[51] R. E., Hall, B., Bowerman, J., Braverman, J., Taylor and H., Todosow, The vision of a smart city. 2nd Int. Life …, 28, p. 7, 2000.

[52] C. Harrison et al., Foundations for Smarter Cities. IBM J. Res. Dev., 54(4), 2010.

[53] R. G., Hollands, Will the real smart city please stand up? Intelligent, progressive or entrepreneurial?. City, 12(3), pp. 303–320, 2008.

[54] Rios, ‘ The Smart City ’ Table of Contents. Development, 2008.

[55] A., Caragliu, C., del Bo, and P., Nijkamp, Smart cities in Europe. J. Urban Technol., 18(2), pp. 65–82, 2009.

[56] T., Chen, Smart grids, smart cities need better networks. IEEE Netw., 24(2), pp. 2–3, 2010.

[57] J. M., Barrionuevo, P., Berrone and J. E., Ricart Costa, Smart Cities, Sustainable Progress: Opportunities for Urban Development. IESE Insight, 14, pp. 50–57, 2012.

[58] P., Neirotti, A., De Marco, A. C., Cagliano, G., Mangano and F., Scorrano, Current trends in smart city initiatives: Some stylised facts. Cities, 38, June, pp. 25–36, 2014.

[59] H., Ahvenniemi, A., Huovila, I., Pinto-Seppä and M., Airaksinen, What are the differences between sustainable and smart cities?. Cities, 60, pp. 234–245, 2017.

[60] S., Van der Graaf and C., Veeckman, Designing for participatory governance: Assessing capabilities and toolkits in public service delivery. Info, 16(6), pp. 74–88, 2014.

[61] V., Albino, U., Berardi and R. M., Dangelico, Smart cities: Definitions, dimensions, performance, and initiatives. J. Urban Technol., 22(1), pp. 3–21, 2015.

[62] B., Trivellato, How can ‘smart’ also be socially sustainable? Insights from the case of Milan. Eur. Urban Reg. Stud., 24(4), pp. 337–351, 2017.

[63] D., Correia and J., Feio, The Smart City as a Social Policy Actor, in International Conferences ICT, Society, and Human Beings, 2020.

[64] B. N., Silva, M., Khan and K., Han, Towards sustainable smart cities: A review of trends, architectures, components, and open challenges in smart cities. Sustain. Cities Soc., 38, January, pp. 697–713, 2018.

[65] D., Hemment, M., Woods, V., Appadoo and L., Bui, Community Key Performance Indicators (Community KPIs) for the IoT and Smart Cities, 2016.

[66] F., Russo, C., Rindone and P., Panuccio, The process of smart city definition at an EU level. WIT Trans. Ecol. Environ., 191, pp. 979–989, 2014.

[67] European Commission, Communication from the commission - Europe 2020. A strategy for smart, sustainable and inclusive growth, [Online]. Available: https://eur-lex.europa. eu/LexUriServ/, 2010 [Accessed: 04-Aug-2021].

[68] D., Correia, L., Teixeira and J., Marques, Triangular Pyramid Trunk: the Three Axes of the Smart City Assessment Tool. WIT Trans. Ecol. Environ., 241, pp. 79–90, 2020.

[69] European Commission, European Innovation Partnership on Smart Cities and Communities - Strategic Implementation Plan, [Online]. Available: https://www., 2013, [Accessed: 05-Aug-2021].

[70] European Commission, European Innovation Partnership on Smart Cities and Communities Operational Implementation Plan: First Public Draft, [Online]. Available: operational-implementation-plan-oip-v2_en.pdf, 2014 [Accessed: 06-Aug-2021].

[71] J., Wolf, M., Borges, J. L., Marques and E., Castro, Smarter Decisions for Smarter Cities: Lessons Learned from Strategic Plans, pp. 7–30, 2019.

[72] R., Giffinger, Smart cities Ranking of European medium-sized cities. October, 16, October, pp. 13–18, 2007.

[73] A., Ojo, Z., Dzhusupova and E., Curry, Smarter as the New Urban Agenda. Smarter as new urban agenda A Compr. view 21st century city, 11, August 2016, pp. 73–85, 2016.

[74] T., Monfaredzadeh and U., Berardi, How can cities lead the way towards a sustainable, competitive and smart future?. WIT Trans. Ecol. Environ., 191, pp. 1063–1074, 2014.

[75] T., Monfaredzadeh and U., Berardi, Beneath the smart city: Dichotomy between sustainability and competitiveness. Int. J. Sustain. Build. Technol. Urban Dev., 6(3), pp. 140–156, 2015.

[76] A., Sharifi and A., Murayama, A critical review of seven selected neighborhood sustainability assessment tools. Environ. Impact Assess. Rev., 38, pp. 73–87, 2013.

[77] ISO, ISO, [Online]. Available:, 2014, [Accessed: 02-Jun-2019].

[78] A., Sharifi, A critical review of selected smart city assessment tools and indicator sets. J. Clean. Prod., 233, pp. 1269–1283, 2019.

[79] A., Huovila, P., Bosch and M., Airaksinen, Comparative analysis of standardized indicators for Smart sustainable cities : What indicators and standards to use and when ?. Cities, 89, January, pp. 141–153, 2019.

[80] A., Stratigea, A., Leka and M., Panagiotopoulou, In search of indicators for assessing smart and sustainable cities and communities’ performance, 6(1), 2017.

[81] P., Venkat Reddy, A., Siva Krishna and T., Ravi Kumar, Study on concept of smart city and its structural components. Int. J. Civ. Eng. Technol., 8(8), pp. 101–112, 2017.

[82] C., Etezadzadeh, Smart City – Future City? Essentials, 2016.

[83] HM, Treasury, Central Government guidance on evaluation, no. March. 2020.

[84] I. B., Huang, J., Keisler and I., Linkov, Multi-criteria decision analysis in environmental sciences: Ten years of applications and trends. Science of the Total Environment, 409(19) Elsevier, pp. 3578–3594, 01-Sep-2011.

[85] W. W., Cooper, L. M., Seiford and K., Tone, Data Envelopment Analysis: A comprehensive text with models, applications, references and DEA-solver software: Second edition. Springer US, 2007.

[86] F., Schuldt, A., Reschka and M., Maurer, Automotive Systems Engineering II. Automot. Syst. Eng. II, 2018.