Detection Methods of Carcinogens in Estuaries: A Review

Detection Methods of Carcinogens in Estuaries: A Review

A.Malakahmad T.S.Abd Manan  S.Sivapalan 

Civil Engineering Department, Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS, Malaysia

Management and Humanities Department, Universiti Teknologi PETRONAS, Malaysia

31 October 2015
| Citation



About 70% of all cancer deaths occur in low- and middle-income countries. Deaths from cancer worldwide are projected to continue to rise over 13.1 million by 2030. Research indicates that estuaries such as rivers and lakes contain various carcinogenic compounds. The carcinogens are transported from the release points to the intake points. To avoid this phenomenon from happening, fast and accurate detection of carcinogen concentrations in water is crucial. This paper presents a review of various detection methods of carcinogenic compounds in watercourses via biological, physical and chemical approaches. Descriptions of the biological procedures such as chromosomal aberration, Micronucleus assay, Ames test, Salmonella assay, SOS chromotest, Comet assay and organic extraction of XAD with blue rayon are discussed. Physical approaches have the integration of automated detections with science and engineering approaches, particularly sensors. Automated optical sensors, submersible ultraviolet fluorometer sensors, photoelectrochemical sensors with the detection of DNA damage and trihalomethanes sensors for the detection of carcinogenic compounds are also reviewed. Chemical approaches consist of the analysis of extraction, purification and identification of organic contaminants using high-technology equipments such as the atomic absorption spectrophotometer, high-performance liquid chromatography and gas chromatography–mass spectrometry. Carcinogens can be identified accurately using an appropriate method chosen from the available alternatives. The evaluations of detection methods presented in this review are based on advantages and disadvantages, accuracy, speed and time factor of methods and experi- mental procedures by previous scholars. This review contributes as guidance to readers on existing methods within different fields and their exclusive applications on different types of carcinogens in water.


detection methods limitations, water-borne carcinogens, water quality


[1] Weinberg, R.A., The Biology of Cancer, Garland Science, Taylor & Francis Group, LLC: New York and UK, pp. 25–27, 2007.

[2] Kitchin, K.T., Carcinogenicity: Testing, Predicting and Interpreting Chemical Effects, Marcel Dekker: New York, NY, pp. 1–30, 1999.

[3] Wescoat, J.L. & White, G.F., Water for Life: Water Management and Environmental Policy, The Press Syndicate of the University of Cambridge: United Kingdom, pp. 30–50, 2003.

[4] White, A. & Rasmussen, J.B., The genotoxic hazards of domestic wastes in surface waters. Mutation Research, 410, pp. 223–236, 2007.

[5] Saxena, P.B., Chemistry of Polycyclic and Heterocyclic Compounds, Discovery Publishing House: New Delhi, pp. 13–27, 2007.

[6] Luch, A., The Carcinogenic of Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbon, Imperial College Press: London, pp. 1–489, 2004.

[7] Sugimura, T., Wakabayashi, K., Nakagama, H. & Nagao, M., Heterocyclic amines: mutagens/carcinogens produces during cooking of meat and fish. Cancer Science, 95, pp. 290–299, 2004. doi:

[8] Clayson, D.B., Toxicological Carcinogenesis, Lewis Publishers: Boca Raton, FL, pp. 1–50, 2000.

[9] Ngadimin, N.W., Factors Influencing to the Selection of Sewage Treatment Plant, Faculty of Civil Engineering, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia: Malaysia, 2010.

[10] Kadir, M.D.A. & Velayutham, S., The Management of Municipal Wastewater Sludge in Malaysia, Symposium on Sludge Management, Universiti Teknologi Malaysia: Skudai, Malaysia, 1999.

[11] LaGrega, M.D., Buckingham, P.L. & Evans, J.C., Hazardous Waste Management, McGrawHill Companies: New York, NY, pp. 1–1000, 2001.

[12] Laugesen, C.H. & Fryd, O., Sustainable Wastewater Management in Developing Countries: New Paradigm and Case Studies From the Field, American Society of Civil Engineers: Reston, VA, 2009.

[13] Mara, D., Domestic Wastewater Treatment in Developing Countries, Earthscan: London, 2004.

[14] Arceivala, S.J. & Asolekar, S.R., Wastewater Treatment for Pollution Control and Reuse, TataMcGraw-Hill Publishing Company: New Delhi, India, 2007.

[15] Bhunia, P.K., Optimal Design and Operation of Wastewater Treatment Plants, Civil Engineering Department, University of California: Los Angeles, CA, 1986.

[16] Sadiq, R., Rajani, B.B. & Kleiner, Y., Risk analysis for water quality deterioration in distribution, evaluation and control of water loss in urban water networks, Valencia, Spain, June 21–25, National Research Council Canada Publication Archive, pp. 1–26, 2004.

[17] Thakur, J.S., Rao, B.T., Rajwanshi, A., Parwana, H.K. & Kumar, R., Epidemiological study of high cancer among rural agricultural community of Punjab in Northern India. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 5, pp. 399–407, 2008. doi:

[18] Koivusalo, M., Jaakkola, J.J.K., Varliainen, T., Hakulinen, T., Karialainen, S., Pukkala, E. & Tuomisto, J., Drinking water mutagenicity and gastrointestinal and urinary tract cancers: an ecological study in Finland. American Journal of Public Health, 84, pp. 1223–1228, 1994. doi:

[19] Kraybill, H.F., Carcinogenesis induced by trace contaminants in potable water, A Symposium on Carcinogens held by Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Greater New York, New York Academy of Medicine, 54, pp. 413–427, 1978.

[20] Zalina, A., Nik Rosmawati, N.H. & Zaliha, I., Factors associated with preferences for safe drinking water among outpatients at Hospital Universiti Sains Malaysia (HUSM), Kelantan, Malaysia. Health and the Environment Journal, 4(1), pp. 31–41, 2013.

[21] Campbell, N.A. & Reece, J.B., The chemistry of life (Chapter 1). The cell (Chapter 2). Genetics (Chapter 3). Mechanisms of evolution (Chapter 4). The evolutionary history (Chapter 5). Animal form and function (Chapter 7). Campbell Biology, Pearson Education Incorporation: Lake Ave, Glenview Illinois, pp. 1–800, 2009.

[22] Maluszynska, J. & Juchimiuk. J., Plant genotoxicity: a molecular cytogenetic approach in plant bioassays. Journal of Plant Genotoxicity, 56, pp. 177–184, 2005.

[23] Fiskesjö, G., The Allium test in wastewater monitoring. Environmental Toxicology and Water Quality, 8(3), pp. 291–298, 1993. doi:

[24] Fiskesjö, G., The Allium test as a standard in environmental monitoring. Hereditas, 102, pp. 99–112, 1985. doi:

[25] Fenech, M., The Micronucleus assay determination of chromosomal level DNA damage. Methods Molecular Biology, 410, pp. 185–216, 2008. doi:

[26] Ukaegbu, M.C. & Odeigah, P.G.C., The genotoxic effect of sewage effluent on Allium cepa. Report and Opinion, 1(6), pp. 36–41, 2009.

[27] Samuel, O.S., Osuala, F.I. & Odeigah, P.G.C., Cytogenotoxicity evaluation of two effluents using Allium cepa assay. African Journal of Environmental Science and Technology, 41(1), pp. 21–27, 2009.

[28] Abu, N.E. & Mba, K.C., Mutagenicity testing of pharmaceutical effluents on Allium cepa root tips meristems. Journal of Toxicology and Environmental Health Sciences, 3(2), pp. 44–51, 2011.

[29] El-Shahaby, O.A., Abdel Migid, H.M., Soliman, M.I. & Mashaly, I.A., Genotoxicity screening of industrial wastewater using the Allium cepa chromosome aberration assay. Pakistan Journal of Biological Sciences, 6(1), pp. 23–28, 2003. doi:

[30] Monte Egato, L.C., Medeiros, M.D.G., Medeiros, S.R.B.D. & Agnez-Lima, L.F., Cytotoxic and genotoxic potential of surface water from the Pitimbu river, northeastern/RN Brazil. Genetics and Molecular Biology, 30(2), pp. 435–441, 2007. doi:

[31] Rank, J. & Nielsen, M.H., Genotoxicity testing of wastewater sludge using the Allium cepa anaphase-telophase chromosome aberration assay. Mutation Research/Genetic Toxicology and Environmental Mutagenesis, 418(2–3), pp. 113–119, 1998. doi:

[32] Zeng, D.M., Li, Y. & Lin, Q.Q., Pollution monitoring of three rivers passing through Fuzhou City, People’s Republic of China. Mutation Research, 426, pp. 159–161, 1999. doi:

[33] Grant, W.F. & Owens, E.T., Chromosome aberration assays in Crepis for the study of environmental mutagens. Mutation Research/Reviews in Mutation Research, 410, pp. 291–307, 1998. doi:

[34] Sang, N. & Li, G., Genotoxicity of municipal landfill leachate on root tips of Vicia faba. Mutation Research, 560, pp. 159–165, 2004. doi:

[35] Levski, J.M. & Singer, R.H., Gene expression and the myth of the average cell. Trends in Cell Biology, 13, pp. 4–6, 2003. doi:

[36] Mortelmans, K. & Zeiger, E., The Ames, Salmonella/Microsome mutagenicity assay. Mutation Research, 455, pp. 29–60, 2000. doi:

[37] Beudot, C., De Me´o, M.P., Dauzonne, D., Elias, R., Laget, M., Guiraud, H., Balansard, G. & Dume´nil, G., Evaluation of the mutagenicity and antimutagenicity of forty-two 3-substituted flavones in the Ames test. Mutation Research, 417, 141–153, 1998. doi:

[38] Cerná, M., Pastorková, A., Šmíd, J., Bavorová, H., Očadlíkoví, D., Rössner P. & Zavadil. J., Genotoxicity of industrial effluents, river waters and their fractions using the Ames test and in vitro cytogenetic assay. Toxicology Letters, 88, pp. 191–197, 1996. doi:

[39] Rehana, Z., Malik, A. & Ahmad, M., Genotoxicity of the Ganges water at Narora (U.P.), India. Mutation Research, 367, pp. 187–193, 1996. doi:

[40] Takamura-Enya, T., Watanabe, T., Tada, A., Hirayama, T., Nukaya, H., Sugimura, T. & Wakabayashi, K., Identification of a new mutagenic polychlorinated biphenyl derivative in the Waka river, Wakayama, Japan, showing activation of an aryl hydrocarbon receptor-dependent transcription. Chemical Research Toxicology, 15, pp. 419–425, 2002. doi:

[41] Lemos, A.T., Rosa, D.P., Rocha, J.A.V. & Vargas, V.M.F., Mutagenicity assessment in a river basin influenced by agricultural, urban and industrial sources. Ecotoxicology and Environmental, 72, pp. 2058–2065, 2009. doi:

[42] Balasubramanyam, A., Sailaja, N., Mahboob, M., Rahman, M.F., Hussain, S.M. & Grover, P., In vitro mutagenicity assessment of aluminium oxide nanomaterials using the Salmonella/Microsome Assay. Toxicology In Vitro, 24, pp. 1871–1876, 2010. doi:

[43] White, P.A., Rasmussen, J.B. & Blaise, C., A semi-automated, microplate version of the SOS Chromotest for the analysis of complex environmental extracts. Mutation Research, 360, pp. 51–74, 1996. doi:

[44] Ohe, T., Quantification of mutagenic/carcinogenic heterocyclic amines, MeIQx, Trp-P-1, Trp-P-2 and PhIP, contributing highly to genotoxicity of river water. Mutation Research, 393, pp. 73–79, 1997. doi:

[45] Jolibois, B. & Guerbet, M., Evaluation of industrial, hospital and domestic wastewater genotoxicity with the Salmonella fluctuation test and the SOS chromotest. Mutation Research, 565, pp. 151–162, 2005. doi:

[46] Ostling, O. & Johansson, K.J., Microelectrophoretic study of radiation-induced DNA damages in individual mammalian cells. Biochemistry & Biophysics Research Community, 123, pp. 291–298, 1984. doi:

[47] Singh, N.P., McCoy, M.T., Tice, R.R. & Schneider, E.L., A simple technique for quantitation of low levels of DNA damage in individual cells. Experiment Cell Research, 175, pp. 184–191, 1988. doi:

[48] Lemos, N.G., Dias, A.L., Silva-Souza, A.T. & Mantovani, M.S., Evaluation of environmental waters using the comet assay in Tilapia rendalli. Environmental Toxicology and Pharmacology,19, pp. 197–201, 2005. doi:

[49] Rocha, P.S., Luvizotto, G.L., Kosmehl, T., Bottcher, M., Storch, V., Braunbeck, T. & Hollert, H., Sediment genotoxicity in the Tiete River (Sao Paulo, Brazil): in vitro Comet assay versus in situ micronucleus assay studies. Ecotoxicology and Environmental Safety, 72, pp. 1842–1848, 2009. doi:

[50] Summak, S., Aydemir, N.C., Vatan, O., Yılmaz, D., Zorlu, T. & Bilaloglu, R., Evaluation of genotoxicity from Nilufer Stream (Bursa/Turkey) water using piscine micronucleus test. Food and Chemical Toxicology, 48, pp. 2443–2447, 2010. doi:

[51] Kummrow, F., Rech, C.M., Coimbrão, C.A., Roubicek, D.A. & Umbuzeiro, G.A., Comparison of the mutagenic activity of XAD4 and blue rayon extracts of surface water and related drinking water samples. Mutation Research, 541, pp. 103–113, 2003. doi:

[52] Oda, Y., Watanabe, T., Taro, Y., Nukaya, H. & Wakabayashi K., Genotoxic activation of 2-phenylbenzotriazole-type compounds by human cytochrome P4501A1 and N-acetyltransferase expressed in Salmonella typhimurium umu strains. Mutation Research, 654, pp. 52–57,2008. doi:

[53] Malakahmad, A., Abd Manan, T.S. & Hilmin, N., Biological procedures to detect carcinogenic compounds in domestic wastewater. WIT Transactions on Ecology and the Environment, 182, WIT Press, 2014, ISN 1743–3541, doi. 10.2495/WP140301.

[54] Tybjerg, K., Wonder-making and philosophical wonder in hero of Alexandria. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part A, 34(3), pp. 443–466, 2003. doi:

[55] Herr, C.M. & Kvan, T., Adapting cellular automata to support the architectural design process. Automation in Construction, 16(1), pp. 61–69, 2007. doi:

[56] Spear, B., James Watt: The steam engine and the commercialization of patents. World Patent Information, 30(1), pp. 53–58, 2008. doi:

[57] Cat, J., On understanding: Maxwell on the methods of illustration and scientific metaphor. Studies in History and Philosophy of Science Part B: Studies in History and Philosophy of Modern Physics, 32(3), pp. 395–441, 2001. doi:

[58] Safonov, M.G., Origins of Robust control: early history and future speculations. Annual Reviews in Control, 36(2), pp. 173–181, 2012. doi:

[59] Krotov, V.F. & Kurzhanski, A.B., National achievements in control theory: the aerospace perspective. Annual Reviews in Control, 29(1), pp. 13–31, 2005. doi:

[60] Chang, T.H., Chueh, C.H. & Yang L.K., Dynamic prediction for insufficient data roadways via automatic control theories. Control Engineering Practice, 19(12), pp. 1479–1489, 2011. doi:

[61] Alavi, S.M.M., Walsh M.J. & Hayes M.J., Robust distributed active power control technique for IEEE 802.15.4 wireless sensor networks-a quantitative feedback theory approach. Control Engineering Practice, 17(7), pp. 805–814, 2009. doi:

[62] Dybko, A., Automated Measuring System Based on Optical Sensors for Water Analysis, XIX IMEKO World Congress Fundamental and Applied Metrology: Lisbon, Portugal, pp. 2243–2246, 2009.

[63] Tedetti, M., Guigue, C. & Goutx, M., Utilization of a submersible UV fluorometer for monitoring anthropogenic inputs in the Mediterranean coastal waters. Marine Pollution Bulletin, 60, pp. 350–362, 2010. doi:

[64] Ahmed, M.J., Zhang, B.T. & Guo, L.H., Photoelectrochemical sensors for the rapid detection of DNA damage by some nanoparticles. Pakistan Journal Analytical Chemistry, 11(1),pp. 8–15, 2010.

[65] National Primary Drinking Water Regulations; Environmental Protection Agency, Online,

[66] Kruger, K.C.C., Formation and Novel Sensing of Trihalomethanes in Drinking Water, Arizona State University: Tempe, AZ, 2007.

[67] Burns, D.T., Aspects of the development of colorimetric analysis and quantitative molecular spectroscopy in the ultraviolet-visible region. Analytical Spectroscopy Library, 2, pp. 1–19,1987. doi:

[68] Behari, J.R. & Prakash, R., Determination of total arsenic content in water by atomic absorption spectroscopy (AAS) using vapour generation assembly (VGA). Chemosphere, 63,pp. 17–21, 2006. doi:

[69] Assubaie, F.N., Assessment of the levels of some heavy metals in water in Alahsa Oasis farms, Saudi Arabia, with analysis by atomic absorption spectrophotometry. Arabian Journal of Chemistry, King Saud University (online), doi:10.1016/j.arabjc.2011.08.018.

[70] Heftmann, E., Chapter 2: History of chromatography and electrophoresis. Journal of Chromatography Library Part A, 22, pp. A19–A26, 1983. doi:

[71] Kataoka, H., Methods for the determination of mutagenic heterocyclic amines and their applications in environmental analysis. Journal of Chromatography A, 774, pp. 121–142,1997. doi:

[72] Cassella, R.J., Sant’Anab, O.D. & Santelli, R.E., Determination of arsenic in petroleum refinery streams by electrothermal atomic absorption spectrometry after multivariate optimization based on Doehlert design. Spectrochim Acta Part B: At Spectroscopy, 57, pp. 1967–1978, 2002. doi:

[73] Neue, U.D., HPLC Columns Theory, Technology and Practice, John Wiley & Sons, Incorporation: New York, NY, 1997.

[74] Sharma, K.S., Mass spectrometry – the early years. International Journal of Mass Spectrometry, 349–350, pp. 3–8, 2013. doi:

[75] Snyder, L.R., Kirkland, J.J. & Dolan, J.W., Introduction to Modern Liquid Chromatography, John Wiley & Sons, Inc: Hoboken, NJ, 2010.

[76] Portoles, T., Pitarch, E., Francisco, J.L. & Hernandez, F., Development and validation of a rapid and wide-scope qualitative screening method for detection and identification of organic pollutants in natural water and wastewater by gas chromatography time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Journal of Chromatography A, 1218, pp. 303–315, 2011. doi:

[77] National Cancer Research Institute: Comprehensive cancer information (Online),

[78] Van Delft, J.H., Van Agen, E., Van Breda, S.G., Herwijnen, M.H., Staal, Y.C. & Kleinjans, J.C., Discrimination of genotoxic from non-genotoxic carcinogens by gene expression profiling. Carcinogenesis, 25, pp. 1265–1276, 2004. doi:

[79] Hernández, L.G., Van Steeg, H., Luijten, M. & Van Benthem, J., Mechanisms of non-genotoxic carcinogens and importance of a weight of evidence approach. Mutation Research, 682, pp. 94–109, 2009. doi:

[80] Hayashi, Y., Overview of genotoxic carcinogens and non-genotoxic carcinogens. Exp Toxicol Pathol, 44, pp. 465–471, 1992. doi:

[81] IARC, Overall evaluations of carcinogenicity: an updating of IARC Monographs, Lyon, International Agency for Research on Cancer, IARC Monographs on the Evaluation of the Carcinogenic Risk of Chemicals to Humans, Supplement 7, 1–42, p. 403, 1987.

[82] WHO Guidelines for drinking-water quality, Volume 1: Recommendations, pp. 66–68; Volume 2: Health Criteria and Other Supporting Information. WHO: Geneva, 2, pp. 185–186, 1984.

[83] A guide to the globally harmonized system of classification and labelling of chemical (GHS)(online),

[84] U.S. Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS), Public Health Service Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, Division of Toxicology/Toxicology Information, Atlanta, GA, 1995.